Side by side

Merlot vs Syrah (Shiraz): tasting notes side by side

Both are dry reds, and neither is sweet. Syrah, called Shiraz in Australia, is full-bodied with medium-high tannin, blueberry and black plum, and pepper. Merlot is soft and round, with a medium to full body, and red plum and cherry in cooler climates or baked blackberry in warmer ones. Both have medium acidity.

Merlot and Syrah / Shiraz, line by line

These are the typical styles of each grape, not two particular bottles, so a wine in your glass may differ. Each line reads from our worked example for the grape.

Line of the noteMerlotSyrah / Shiraz
SweetnessDry. Ripe fruit can give a sweet impression even when there is no sugar left in the wine.Dry.
AcidityMedium. Refreshing, but not high.Medium.
TanninSoft and round. Guides rate it anywhere from low to medium-high, and it varies with climate and winemaking.Medium-high.
BodyMedium to full. Warmer-climate wines are fuller.Full.
AlcoholUsually 13.5 to 15% ABV. Check the label.Usually 13.5 to 15% ABV. Check the label.
Typical aromasRed plum and cherry in cooler climates. Baked blackberry and fruitcake in warmer ones. When fully ripe it can also show blackcurrant, blueberry and chocolate. Vanilla and spice if it was aged in oak. A grassy or bell-pepper note can appear in cool-climate wines. Earthy, meaty and chocolate notes can develop with age.Blueberry and black plum. Cooler places lean to raspberry. Warmer ones move to blackberry and chocolate. Spice and savoury: Pepper, including green peppercorn, plus tobacco. The northern Rhône can also show smoke, flowers and mint.

Read the full tasting note for each grape

Each page has a worked note written line by line and a free blank sheet to fill in.

Questions

Which is sweeter, Merlot or Shiraz?

Neither is sweet. Wine Folly lists both as dry. Merlot's ripe fruit can give a sweet impression, even when there is no sugar left in the wine. Judge sweetness on its own, apart from how ripe the fruit seems.

What is the difference in taste?

Syrah tastes of blueberry and black plum, with pepper and tobacco. Cooler places lean to raspberry, and warmer ones to blackberry and chocolate. Older Syrah can turn to tar and game. Merlot tastes of red plum and cherry in cooler climates, and baked blackberry and fruitcake in warmer ones, often with vanilla and spice from oak.

How do I tell them apart in the glass?

Smell for pepper first. Black or green peppercorn points to Syrah. Do not mix it up with the grassy, bell-pepper note some cool-climate Merlot has. Red plum and cherry point to Merlot. Dark fruit alone can mislead, because ripe Merlot can also show blueberry and chocolate. On the palate, Syrah is full-bodied, and Merlot runs from medium to full, so a lighter wine leans to Merlot. Tannin is a weaker clue: Syrah is medium-high, and guides rate Merlot anywhere from low to medium-high. Acidity and alcohol will not help, because both are medium in acidity and usually 13.5 to 15% ABV.

Sources

The typical aromas and structure above come from these grape guides.

More comparisons